The Dearly Beloved: A Novel by Cara Wall is about two married couples whose lives are intertwined with each other. In 1963, in Greenwich Village, NYC, Charles and James met for the first time. They are both hired as co-pastors for the historic Third Presbyterian Church. The pair seem to get along well but they have different personal ideas and goals about the church and their lives.
Charles was expected to follow in his father’s footsteps. His father is a respected history professor at Harvard. However, a popular professor had invited Charles to a lecture in the school’s basement, and his life’s trajectory changed. He learns about faith and realizes that he wants to have a career in ministry. His family is horrified by his decision and to make matters worse, he falls for a woman, Lily, who doesn’t believe in God.
James is the youngest son from a low-income Chicago family. He spent most of his youth angry and avoiding his alcoholic war veteran father and escaping from the rest of his family. James receives an unexpected windfall from his uncle that allows him to attend college. While in school, he comes across Nan, who he falls in love with. Nan grew up in Mississippi and is the devout and devoted daughter of a minister. James uses Nan and her faith as a guiding compass when he feels his faith wavering.
The book was an okay read. I didn’t realize it was going to be heavily focused on religion and faith. Personally, this isn’t the type of fiction I like reading. I found the book to be very boring and slow. I felt like nothing happened for long periods. The storyline was predictable, and I found myself yawning throughout the book. At times, I felt like the pacing of the novel was off. The beginning was slow, the middle picked up, and the ending was a rushed chaotic mess. I also didn’t like how they referred to Will, who is autistic. The author commented on how he was a gargoyle but with “proper training and education”, he became a child. I feel like that is implying children with special needs are not seen as human. Readers who like reading about people finding or struggling to find their faith might enjoy this novel more than me.