I have been a long time fan of Mally Beauty's eye liner. They are creamy smooth and once they go on, they stay on! If you want to smudge the eyeliner you have a quick 30 seconds after application otherwise the product stays put. I do like even though it doesn't run, crease, smudge or budge -- it is still easy to remove with makeup remover. The navy blue eyeliner had a bit of gray glitter which works both for the daytime and a smokey look for the nighttime.