Book Review - Sweet Pea Summer by Alys Murray

 

Sweet Pea Summer by Alys Murray is about high school sweethearts reconnecting later in life. Eight years ago, May Anderson made the biggest mistake of her life. She broke up with her high school boyfriend, Tom Riley, and watched him leave their hometown, Hillsboro, California, without her. She felt that moment has changed the entire trajectory of her life and it has been one of her greatest regrets. May is unprepared when she finds out that Tom is back home.

Tom would rather spend his time alone but his family’s vineyard is failing. He joins forces with May to organize the prestigious Northwest Food and Wine Festival. He hopes that the festival can help bring business to the winery. However, Tom is having a hard time putting the past behind him and working side by side with May, especially since she broke his heart years ago. May finds Tom even more irresistible than before and she can’t seem to move on. Will the pair be able to work out their differences to make the festival successful?

The book wasn’t for me.  I didn’t really care for any of the characters. I found May to be annoying. She complained that she wanted to leave Hillsboro because her entire time there she only made one friend. And then she left that one friend because of what other people (not friends) have told her. She claims that that was her biggest mistake but then she continues to make the same mistake. She doesn’t trust her friend, Annie, or even her sisters to be open with her feelings or trust them with the truth about her breakup.

I also don’t see why May is hesitant to leave the small town or how she was considered the “town’s sweetheart”, as she just seemed selfish and mostly kept to herself. I haven’t seen any examples of the town being supportive. May’s father said to her that the town was suffocating her creativity and spirit. May’s sisters seemed bland and one-dimensional. I felt like they were barely present in the story and didn’t really add much to it.

I don’t understand why Tom kept May’s secret when she seems to be betraying his trust and choosing her needs over his all the time. He kept saying it’s not his place to tell the secret but, the secret did involve him so, why wouldn’t it involve him? He also said he wanted to tell people the truth and told his grandmother but was very selective later on telling people the truth or even defending himself. 

I also didn’t understand why the two of them were pining over each other for years. I understand that they were friends and were in love but we got no glimpses of that love and tenderness since May was continuously letting Tom be used as a punching bag by the town. The novel mostly focused on their boring romance and the planning of the festival mostly happened in the back end. I felt that the story was repetitive and kept saying the same thing over and over without much happening. I had started reading another book by the author years ago and had stopped reading it because it was boring. I feel like I should have trusted my previous judgment and just skipped this one as well.