Church of Marvels by Leslie Parry is about a woman, Odile Church, searching for her sister, Belle, after their mother dies in a fire.
Set in 1895 New York, Sylvan Threadgill works as a night soiler, cleaning out the privies near tenement houses. While working one night, he discovers a newborn baby abandoned in the muck. Since Sylvan was once an orphan himself, he takes pity on the child and rescues her. Determined to help, he sets out to find a safe place for the baby.
Odile and Belle Church are twins who were raised in the Church of Marvels, a sideshow act in Coney Island. After a tragic accident, their home burns to the ground with their mother inside. Odile is devastated when she learns that Belle has fled to Manhattan without a trace, and she becomes desperate to find her sister.
Meanwhile, Alphie, a young woman, wakes up across the river in Blackwell’s Lunatic Asylum. At first, she has no idea where she is until she remembers that her husband’s cruel mother had her committed. While trapped in the asylum, she meets another beautiful young woman who refuses to speak to anyone. However, Alphie soon discovers that the mysterious woman has a hidden talent that might help them escape.
I thought the book was an okay read overall. It is told through alternating perspectives, which was a lot to keep track of in the beginning. The book did have a few unexpected twists that I didn’t see coming. However, I also felt like it was slow and boring at times, and the constant narrator changes could feel jarring. I never really connected with or cared much about any of the characters. While we were given some backstory for each of them, I didn’t feel like it was enough to make me truly root for them. Overall, it was an okay book, but I wouldn’t go out of my way to read another book by the author.




