Kaplan’s Plot by Jason Diamond follows Elijah Mendes, who returns home to Chicago to care for his dying mother and uncovers a dark secret about his family’s past. Elijah had hoped that if he ever returned home, it would be under better circumstances. His mother, Eve, is dying of cancer, his business collapsed after a damaging scandal, and he has nowhere else to go.
Elijah comes home feeling restless and uncertain about his future. While he wants to help his mother, he struggles with how to do so because their relationship has long been distant and strained. While assisting her in organizing the house, Elijah discovers a letter addressed to his mother that references a Jewish cemetery owned by their family. The letter also mentions a man Elijah has never heard of, his great-uncle, Solomon Kaplan, who is buried there.
Using the letter as a starting point, Elijah confronts his mother and begins to learn more about their family history. He discovers that Eve’s father, Yitz, was a powerful and notorious gangster in the 1920s. Ashamed of her father’s criminal past, Eve had buried the truth and never spoken of it. As Elijah digs deeper into his family’s history, he realizes that uncovering these long-hidden secrets may offer him and his mother a chance to finally connect.
I wasn’t sure what to expect from this book based on the synopsis. I felt conflicted while reading it. I enjoyed the chapters set in the past, but found the present-day storyline dull and unengaging. The sections focused on Yitz and his past were by far the most interesting, while Elijah’s storyline felt unnecessary, as very little actually happened.
I struggled to understand the point of the novel, as it often felt unfocused and disjointed. At times, I was confused about what was happening or why certain scenes were included at all. I also didn’t enjoy the author’s writing style, which felt padded with too much fluff. While the book was okay, I wouldn’t reread it or seek out other works by this author.




