The Violets of March by Sarah Jio is the story of a woman, Emily Wilson, who discovers a dark secret hidden within her family’s history.
When Emily Wilson was in her twenties, she seemed to have it all. She had written a bestselling novel, had a handsome husband, and shared a beautiful home with him. However, ten years later, everything has changed for the worse. Her husband tells her he is leaving her for another woman, and to make matters worse, Emily has been struggling with writer’s block and is unable to finish a new book.
When her great-aunt Bee invites her to spend a month on Bainbridge Island in Washington State, Emily happily accepts. She hopes that returning to the island, where she made many cherished childhood memories, will help heal her heart and inspire her writing. While staying at her aunt’s house, she discovers a red velvet diary dating back to 1943. As her curiosity grows, Emily begins to suspect that the diary belonged to someone in her family.
I was excited to read this book because the premise sounded interesting. However, as the story progressed, my interest started to wane. The characters felt boring and one-dimensional, and I never found myself rooting for any of them, especially Emily, who kept making what I felt were some questionable decisions.
I also have no idea why almost every person connected to the diary seemed to change their name and refuse to talk about the past. It felt like they wanted to tell the story, but kept dragging their feet for no real reason, and Emily seemed in no rush to find any answers. Several moments felt unbelievable to me. For example, an elderly woman serving as a pallbearer seemed odd, and one character suddenly revealed she had cancer, and only a month to live, came completely out of nowhere. It was especially strange since she had apparently never mentioned it to her best friend. The insta-love between some of the characters felt equally unrealistic.
Overall, I felt there were too many coincidences and implausible moments throughout the story. There were also quite a few loose ends that left me wanting more answers. While the premise had a lot of potential, the execution ultimately fell flat for me.




