Hank and Henry Stick With It - Blickity Black Eyeliner

I have heard many good things about this brand but, this was my first Hank and Henry product. I was very excited to try the eyeliner because it was a very hyped up product. I was sadly disappointed at the quality of both the product and the packaging. The eyeliner came out very watery and bleed. And usually, the product would start pooling by the tip. And no matter how gently and how I stored the eyeliner, the top would fray the brush making it look dingy after just two uses. For $20, I expected better.

Clio Gelpresso Waterproof Pencil Gel Eyeliner - Golden Black

The gel eyeliner is richly pigmented and it glides on smoothly. It didn't tug or rub when I was applying it. It also stayed put all day without smudging or fading. I read that it is called Golden Black because it has gold sparkles but, I didn't really notice it.

Sumita Beauty Raina Contrast Eye Pencil - Midnight Blue

The creamy eyeliner went on smoothly and imparts a rich deep Midnight blue. Enriched with luxe oils, the waterproof eyeliner goes on and stays put.

Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner - Gilded

The creamy eye liner goes on smoothly and stays put. It doesn't fade or budge throughout the day. The gilded color is a golden bronze color with a hint of shimmer. The only downside, some of the smudge stick doesn't turn very well and get stuck.

Pixi Endless Silky Eye Pen - No.2 BlackBlue

The creamy eyeliner goes on smoothly but smudges very easily. After a while, the satin finished eyeliner just melts away and disappears away. The pencil sharpens nicely but the cream eyeliner sometimes melts and gets stuck in the sharpener or just breaks off. The eyeliner is enriched with vitamin E and natural mineral pigments and is paraben, mineral oil,  and preservative free. The eyeliner is a beautiful blue black color with a hint of glimmer.

Xtreme Lashes GlideLiner Long Lasting Eye Pencil - 185 Black Pearl

The creamy long lasting gel eyeliner is enriched with vitamin E. It goes on smoothly and smudges well for 2 seconds before staying put all day. I love the color and how it goes on. But it was very hard to do a small line and the eyeliner goes on very thickly. Also, don't press too hard because the point keeps breaking off for me. :(