Makeup Forever Aqua Eyes - Matte Black 0L

The creamy eyeliner is an intense burst of long-lasting color. The eyeliner glides on easily and doesn't smudge and fade throughout the day. The waterproof eyeliner was originally created for the Parisian Aquatic Ballet and was tested under water for five hours. The eyeliner goes on smooth and lasted awhile for me. I love how creamy and easy was to apply. However, I found the black to be a bit duller compared to other eyeliners.

Mally Beauty Evercolor Starlight Waterproof Eye Liner - Sailor

I have been a long time fan of Mally Beauty's eye liner. They are creamy smooth and once they go on, they stay on! If you want to smudge the eyeliner you have a quick 30 seconds after application otherwise the product stays put. I do like even though it doesn't run, crease, smudge or budge  -- it is still easy to remove with makeup remover. The navy blue eyeliner had a bit of gray glitter which works both for the daytime and a smokey look for the nighttime.

Pixi Endless Silky Eye Pen - No.6 True Teal

I have always been a fan of Pixi products and I can see why this eyeliner is a cult favorite. The formula goes on creamy and stay put. The highly pigmented teal pencil is waterproof and smudge proof. Like all the other Pixi products, it doesn't contain any parabens or mineral oils and it's not tested on animals. There are 10 colors in the line and I can't wait to try the rest.

Cynthia Rowley Beauty Eyeliner - Silver

The creamy luxe liner delivers a bold bright silver blast of color. The vegan formula is cruelty and paraben free. The eyeliner is  covered in a slick black package and  wrapped with a signature gold foil design. The eyeliner stays put but it is smudge-able within 30 seconds of application.

Too Faced Lava Gloss Glossy Black Eyeliner

The creamy eyeliner goes on smoothly. It is also very smudgeable and blends easily without tugging. It good for a cat eye but it doesn't go easily on the waterline. Overall, a mediocre eyeliner.

Tosowoong Gel Pencil Liner - 08 Aqua Deep Blue

The gel pencil glides on easy for smooth coverage. It has staying power to last all day. I love the navy color has a bit of a sparkle but not enough where I can't wear it during the daytime.